Commission to Consider Hunting Technology Changes

Following a presentation on recent changes in archery and muzzleloader technology, Idaho Fish and Game Commissioners discussed the issue briefly but took no action during their recent meeting in Lewiston. Commissioners are expected to take up the issue during their meeting January 10 - 12 in Boise. Advances in hunting equipment technology challenges wildlife managers who must balance the desires of some hunters, who want to use the most efficient and effective technology, with sustainable harvest rates and equitable hunting opportunities, said Brad Compton, big game manager with the Department of Fish and Game. Some technology changes improve hunter effectiveness, which could result in shorter seasons or other limits to maintain game populations. The advances in archery and muzzleloader technology in particular have increased, as have the requests for changes in Idaho's current regulations, adopted in 1991. Commissioners recognized that the intent of a muzzleloader hunt was to allow hunters who use traditional muzzle-loading hunting rifles, which have limited range and reliability, an opportunity to hunt without competition from modern weapons. Traditional muzzleloader hunting seasons require open sights, no scope or electronic devices, loose powder and round balls or conical bullets made solely of lead. Some muzzleloaders using modern technology - including synthetic black powder pellets, plastic "sabots" or boots on bullets, and internal hammers - are considered as effective as a .30-30 rifle, with a similar range. The commission directed the department to solicit public comments on whether non-traditional muzzle-loading weapons should be included in any-weapon seasons rather than a season of their own. Commissioners also directed the department to seek comments on changes to current restrictions on archery equipment, including let-off and arrow weight. Fish and Game plans regional open houses to discuss muzzleloader and archery technology issues before the commission meets again in January.